Monday, January 5, 2009

Financial Melt Down

Lots to write about as we ease into the New Year.  Of course, there is more than enough material on the economy.  But first, this just in, the financial system upon which ours and the global economy is based, is in a melt down!

Yesterday, in the New York Times Michael Lewis wrote a fantastic piece focused on the lack of regulatory oversight on the financial markets: banks, hedge funds, the stock markets.  It is, in my opinion, a must read.

Two salient points in his article.  First, something we have all known, but the revolving door between government and the industries (we saw this a lot with high powered Senators and Congressmen becoming lobbyists for the very industries they used to legislate) government regulates is a huge problem.  Lewis focused primarily on the Securities and Exchange Commission, but this regulator becomes highly paid employee routine exists in all sectors, not just finance.  It goes without saying, but Lewis drills in the point, that regulators are loathe to enforce when they know they will be seeking lucrative jobs from the very industries they are monitoring.  In the case of the financial sector, particularly the risk markets such as stocks and securities, the enforcement of regulations has become, according to Lewis, a joke.  Unfortunately, it became a very very scary joke as we now are having to deal with all the failures.

Because of the cozy relationships between regulator and regulatee, Lewis maintains the SEC has become more about protecting "predator" corporations from the public rather than the public from predatory securities schemes.  My aside to that reflection is that it is true for much of government regulatory agencies.  If you can afford a lobbyist presence in Washington, DC, you have more access to government "protection" than the rest of us.

Second, and in my opinion the more important point made by Lewis, was the emphasis over the past two decades on corporations short term gains.  The incentives for CEOs, boards of directors, and managers, is to work toward quarterly profits rather than long term health of the company much less (and this is my gripe not Lewis's) producing anything of lasting value.  And when you're driving for immediate results, you of course tend to do things which are not in the best interests of anyone other than your own wallet.  

It seems to me that the current melt down is an opportunity to re-build the whole mechanism, not just tinker trying to instill confidence.  I'm not sure, frankly, we can instill confidence in something so broken.  I am also not sure layers and layers of regulation are the answer, but I do think we need to enforce the laws we have.  At the risk of sounding harsh, it seems to me the enforcers failed.  Do they still have jobs?  Are they still monitoring banks, companies, the stock market?  In any other situation, if there was such a large and massive failure, jobs would be lost.  So, let's get new people in those positions, someone who ensures they do their job, and Congressional oversight to make sure the boss is actually accomplishing something.  But we also need to re-think how we want corporate America to act as well as how we save, borrow, and lend money.  

In the meantime, real people are enduring real pain.  If we don't spend the time, now, working on re-building, you can bet we'll be looking at the smoldering rubble again.


Friday, January 2, 2009

Seasons and Calendars

This morning I carried the ornament box up from the basement.  Bills that languished on my desk were opened, checks written, note made to buy stamps (did I really send out that many Christmas cards?).  I turned on my stereo (yes, I am still iPodless) and played Christmas music one more time.  It's ok, it's only January 2nd.  Doesn't some religion celebrate Christmas in early January?  Thank you notes are written to sad Celtic Christmas music.

I check mountain pass reports, half expecting that all the snow from Wednesday, when it was still December, is melted by today, two days into January.  With new calendars hung (yes, I am still old fashioned and actually hang calendars rather than rely on my computer), I half expect it to be a new season.

But we are still in winter.  In reality, we are only a few days into that season.  Long nights, short days, darkness by the late afternoon walk with my dog.  We've had a series of unusual snow storms here in Seattle, all which has finally melted and we are back to our usual gray weather.

In less than 18 days there will be another change, a new President and his administration.  Barack Obama ran an enormously successful campaign on themes of hope and change.  Unlike any candidate I have seen since John F. Kennedy or maybe Ronald Reagan, Obama has engendered an adoration that still seems to linger even among the most cynical of my friends.  He carries so many expectations on his shoulders.  And in this severest of political and economic winters, where it seems policies are frozen and entrenched, the economy seems unable to provide refuge to even the most privileged among us, Obama and his advisors have their work cut out for them.  To thaw international hostilities built over hundreds of years, to unwind economic disasters, to help people find a sense of well being in this frozen landscape.

It will still be winter when Barack Obama is sworn in on January 20th.  The calendar says it will be two more months until we can begin to see signs of Spring.  But somehow as I put up new calendars and began cleaning from the holidays I felt as if this winter, maybe just this winter, there would be a warm wind blowing mid-month.

Tuesday, December 30, 2008

Making Government Cool


Barack Obama apparently wants to make working for the government cool.  Having worked in that sector several times (mostly on the legislative side) I think that is great.  I was never, however, aware that working for the government wasn't cool...but then,  I am definitely not the arbiter of what is cool.

I have a few thoughts about what government has become, though.

Here in Seattle we have just emerged from two weeks of snow and ice.  The City refused to use any de-icing mechanisms on the roads because, apparently, they were worried about salt going into Puget Sound (which, by the way, is a salt water body).  Of course, what they did instead was use sand.  Tons and tons of sand, which the impacts of the increased sediment load into Puget Sound has a far greater probability of impacting species such as salmon, than the diluted salt.  

So, because the roads became essentially impassible for two weeks there were enormous transportation impacts.  Our city, like every other city in the US, is rushing to find money for trolleys, yet the one trolley line we have now, covering about a mile through the north end of downtown to South Lake Union, never ran.  Too much snow on the tracks.  We have become a city that wants people to get out of their cars, yet, few if any buses were able to operate.  Deliveries from UPS to FedEx were not able to be made.  When people started complaining, Jan Drago, a City Councilwoman was quoted in the newspaper as saying she didn't have any problems getting around in her 4 wheel drive SUV.

And of course, garbage was never picked up.  So today in the newspaper, the director of the public utility was quoted as saying garbage pick up will resume on normal schedules on Monday, and oh, by the way, we won't be charged for extra garbage!  What!

Between the "I get around in my SUV so why are people complaining?" and the arrogance of "people won't be charged for extra garbage," I think, at least in this city, our government has forgotten who they work for.  

Council woman Drago should have gotten out of her SUV (which by the way, she consistently votes for reducing parking spaces in high density housing, for spending money on trolleys and other transit methods, so what is she doing owning an SUV much less driving around in it?) and found out how 9/10ths of the city was dealing with the mess.  The head of the public utility should have been apologizing and saying something like: "we understand people will have more garbage than normal and we look forward to making sure every thing is picked up and restored back to normal.  In fact, because we missed pick-ups we are giving every one a credit on their next bills."

A neighbor recently told me about an encounter he had with the building department.  His house apparently is out of compliance with the code because a prior owner built a bedroom in what was the garage without a permit.  As he struggled to get the permits to bring everything back into code, a planner looked at him and said: "gotcha'."

Maybe this is a Seattle thing.  But I have experience the same arrogance with state employees, and don't even get me started on some encounters I have had with the feds.   Of course there are great civil servants.  People who want to do a good job for us.  Empirically, though, I think they are an anomaly, not the standard.  It should, of course, be the other way around.

So, Mr. President elect, if you're going to make working for the government cool, please remember it starts at the top.  Each and every federal bureaucrat or appointed official must be reminded, daily, that they work for the citizens, not the other way around.  It's not about gotcha's or control or power.  It's about service.  

Sunday, December 28, 2008

Place, Identity, and Work

In Sunday's Washington Post there was a fabulous article about Chesapeake Bay and the slow erosion of the oyster and fishing communities.  

The loss of oyster and fishing jobs on Chesapeake Bay is less about losing a way of life and more about how our culture has evolved from valuing working with our hands, being based in place to a service culture, where placed based work has become irrelevant.  

And in my opinion that is not good.  It is yet again another sign that our economy is not healthy.

One of the consequences that we are seeing in transforming our economy from place based work to service work is the over development of areas like Chesapeake Bay, or Puget Sound, or the Oregon Coast, or Bozeman, Montana, where homes displace fishing, cattle ranching, oystering, yes, even logging.  Our natural resources in some sense become destroyed because of people building where they think they  can appreciate the natural resources.

Perhaps part of this new new economy should address these issues.  Instead of helping people become more mobile, maybe we need to figure out how to help people stay.

Friday, December 26, 2008

Unintended Consequences

Before an initiative was filed to stop it, the City of Seattle was going to join the ranks of many European cities and begin taxing folks for paper or plastic bags at stores.  Now in August, the City Council has put the issue before the voters.

I have almost always taken my bags to the grocery store.  Back in the day, a local grocery store chain, QFC (now owned by Krogers) used to donate 5¢ to the Washington State Nature Conservancy chapter for each bag you re-used.   Currently, Whole Foods gives you a 2¢ credit for every bag you bring in.  

But Seattle wanted to tax you (although they didn't want to call it a tax) 20¢ for each new bag you used.  Some portion of that tax would be retained by the grocer, but the bulk of it would go to the City.

Aside from the issues of people who don't have enough money, forgetting their re-useable bag, or not having enough disposable income for a re-useable bag, much less initiating a tax during a recession (which never seems to get through to Seattlites for some reason) there are several unintended consequences of this tax which concern me.

Obviously there are some good intentions with this tax.  The idea is that plastic and paper bags are filling up our land disposals.  Of course, so are millions of other things, including the paper and plastic bags from other stores not included in the tax.  The tax targets only grocery stores.  And the City is giving out free re-useable bags, which will mitigate, hopefully, the financial impacts on people.  But the idea that we don't have to use so much paper or plastic is good.

However, here are my concerns:

First, the re-useable bags are probably made in China or some other country.  They are made of plastic, and usually contain advertising all over them, which in not so subtle ways encouraging people to consume.  It's the consumption that is the issue, not the miniscule amount of bags which are used.  And the "carbon footprint" of using a plastic bag, or several plastic bags from overseas vastly outsizes the carbon footprint of paper bags manufactured from recycled pulp here in the US.

Second, paper bags are one of the last timber products still made here in this country.  Pulp mills pay good wages.  Many pulp mills are still relatively local.  Heck many pulp mills are still union.

Third, using plastic re-useable bags (which don't appear to be high quality enough to last years and years, but oh, that's the point, right?) encourages more frequent trips to the market.  That is, unless you have a huge collection of re-useable bags.  More frequent trips translates into more fuel, more consumption...In fact, it's a red flag that the local grocery store association supports this tax (they do get a portion of it, and they also know (this from a daughter and granddaughter of a grocer) that more trips to stores = more income for the grocer)

I think the most important unintended consequence are the jobs.  From the haulers of recycled pulp, to mill workers, to cargo truckers, to warehousemen, stockers in the grocery store, there is a whole vertical chain of people who rely on bags for employment.  Over the past few decades we have become rather cavalier about the elimination of jobs in the natural resource and related industries.  Whole communities have been turned into ghost towns while urbanites casually say things like oh, they can be trained to do something else.  Unfortunately the something else usually looks a lot like making mochas in a drive through.  

In environmental economics it is popular to assert that taxing makes people change behaviors.  And more than likely if the City wins in the election next August (which I predict they will by portraying the folks behind the initiative as bad and evil folks from the chemical industry promoting plastic bags), folks in Seattle will reduce their use of paper and plastic bags.  Meanwhile blinders will be on as another industry falls further into decline, more people lose jobs, and other ghost towns are created.

An alternative, I always believe, is to create incentives.  Bring in credits for using re-useable bags.  Educate people about consumption issues, shopping for more and less trips (buy for the week rather than 7 different trips to the grocery store).  Instead of punishing, how about rewarding?  And how about showing communities outside of Seattle, places that depend upon a pulp mill, a warehouse, a trucking outfit, that we understand their issues, too.


Wednesday, December 24, 2008

Heaven and Earth

Forty years ago today, Apollo 8 orbited the Moon and beamed to millions on Earth this miraculous shot, one of the first times we had seen our own planet.  The crew of Apollo 8 then read from the Book of Genesis, ending with wishing those of us down on the "good earth" a Merry Christmas.

And here we are, all too familiar with shots of our planet.  Yet every time I see this photo I gasp.  What an amazing miracle we live upon.

Have a wonderful holiday.  

Tuesday, December 23, 2008

Free Markets?

Sorry no picture with this post.  I spent the better part of today navigating Seattle's snow, slush, and ice, but mostly avoiding people who haven't a clue how to drive when they are scared.  Clearly, most of Seattle has never rented a car in Italy!

But sitting in my SUV washing my own mouth out with soap gave me lots of time to think about free markets.  Finally yesterday's Wall Street Journal arrived this morning.  In it was an editorial about how regulation is stifling innovation and hence capital infusions in Silicon Valley.  My first thought was this op-ed piece must be a joke, then I realized that I have been hearing the "free markets" drum beat for awhile.  

I keep waiting for someone like Paul Krugman to finally blow a gasket and give a succinct lecture on how not only are there no "true" free markets in complex economies, but in fact, those who promote free markets are often the worst abusers of regulation and incentives.  

Someone who has latched onto the idea of free markets is environmentalist Robert Kennedy Jr.  A few years ago he did some interesting writing about how free markets might actually cause companies to clean-up their toxic wastes.  You see, dumping chemicals into a river is considered an externality in economic terms, in other words, it is not figured into the costs of production because our markets, our economy doesn't or hasn't required it to be considered a cost to the business.  Because we do regulate, usually the externality cost is picked up and paid for by, yep, you guessed it, us, the taxpayer.  So, Kennedy thought, what if we actually had free markets where we the taxpayer didn't pick up the cost, but rather leveled the playing field by saying to every company they had to pay the full price of production and we the consumer would pay the full price of the product?

Let's think about this.  In Washington State every few years one of the largest employers, Boeing, lights a fire under our governor or state legislature, saying they will take their production overseas or to some southern state.  In order to stay, they need more tax breaks.  Washington does not have an income tax, so we rely on a sales tax and business and occupation tax.  Indeed, Boeing pays far less tax than a small family run business.  Same thing for the other powerhouse, Microsoft.  Obviously the benefits to the state are keeping people employed, and those employees spend money which the state collects sales tax.  I would guess that the amount of sales tax isn't equal to what those two companies garner in tax breaks.  

Our former Chairman of the Federal Reserve, Alan Greenspan, was a free marketer.  In fact, many free marketers really do believe in the economic theory that people will act in their own economic self interest.  But in October this year, Greenspan finally admitted  that people (more particularly companies) don't always act in what he thought would be their own economic self interest.  The variable that he didn't take into account was the short term self interest rather than the long term well being of companies or even individuals.  

All this is to say think twice when you start hearing the drum beat of free markets need to remain free.  First all, there is no such thing as a free market.  And second, the grey area of semi-regulation either not enforced or non-existent, clearly has failed us.  Often companies use the existence of regulations to nudge or shove competitors out of business (think large timber companies during the Pacific Northwest spotted owl issues), or use the lack of enforcement to continue their short term gluttony (think mortgage brokers selling the now infamous sub-prime mortgages).  Whenever someone talks about the need to keep markets free just think about these past 12 months.  

Quite frankly, my guess is the economy will be a lot healthier if we all admit that there are no free markets and we finally figure out ways to regulate and monitor that enhance creativity in capital and innovation but don't subject the world to these now all too familiar booms and busts.  It seems to me that the Lords of Wall Street can channel their innovation to figuring out how to have a sustainably growing economy rather than how to make a cool million selling toxic securities even they would be better off...maybe proving to Alan Greenspan that people can act in their own economic self interest as well as everyone else's.