Thursday, March 12, 2009

On Greed

This morning, 12 adults, from a female fire fighter to a international banker, sat in front of a elementary school student body to explain what they do for a living.  There was a woman, trained as a hair stylist who founded a children's theatre, a camera man for documentaries seen on The Discovery Channel, a chef who opened his own oven roasted pizza restaurant after being an elementary school teacher, an architect designing affordable housing, a immunologist, a forester (me!), and a director of operas.  Each person spoke passionately about following the things in life that make you happy.  About giving to the community.  Not one student asked about how much money we made (although one precocious child asked if I got to shoot wild animals!).

And so, on this day, when Bernie Madoff was shackled and taken to a Federal Detention Center in Manhattan, when his victims cheered and clapped when he was hauled away, this piece by Tim Egan, says it all.   

I met Patsy Collins (referenced in the article) and worked with Bill Gates, Sr.  Both were and are amazing people.  We have a lot to learn from folks who understand commitment to community, family, and that following your passion is far more important that how much money you can make.  Greed was prevalent throughout our society, especially the past few years.  We're all in the mess together.  And it will take all of us to get us out of it.

Now, now it the time for us, in Patsy Collin's words, to "give forward."   

Wednesday, March 11, 2009

Trusting

Bernie Madoff.  Pfizer.  Peanut butter.  Banks.  The former Governor of Illinois.  The list could go on for institutions and people who seemed to have broken our trust in just the past two months!

Today, we learn another saga in the pharmaceutical companies paying researchers.  In this case, a noted anesthesiologist who had published research about post-operative pain killers, admitted that he fabricated results which were beneficial to Pfizer.  Of course, Pfizer paid for his work.  

The large pharmaceutical company denies any involvement, and in fact, they probably didn't sit down with this researcher and demand certain results, but he clearly wasn't stupid and realized the more his result showed success in post-operative pain relief with Pfizer's non-narcotic drugs, the more likely he would get continued funding, prestige, and probably a larger salary than most anesthesiologists.  

It seems that many of the foundations of our lives are crumbling under daily revelations that our fundamental systems are not working.  Financial institutions, using our deposits, speculated wildly, made irresponsible loans, preyed on people with teaser loan rates, and awarded huge bonuses for short term success and long term devastation.  Our food supply system is broken.  Sucked in by our own greed or need to sustain income levels in order to just keep up, we handed money to not one but many many suave and cultured "investment advisors" who concocted elaborate Ponzi-schemes which eluded regulators for years.  And government officials, from Illinois to Washington, DC, continue to flaunt their power and avoid accountability.

All of this makes things like the Ford Pinto or Chevrolet Corvair seem contained.  We managed to catch those problems, convince the auto companies to build safer cars, and everyone believed they could trust again.  

Now, well now, who would you trust?  

Our collective cultural belief in trust, that people will do the right thing, is broken.  There are somethings government can begin to fix, like insuring that food production is safe, enforcing banking regulations (or creating a new regulatory structure), increasing ethics oversight on government officials, perhaps even increasing government funding for health research.  But really, trust is a covenant between each of us.  We must find ways to put aside our own greed and understand that concept.  Because, as all our mother's once said, when trust is broken....

Tuesday, March 10, 2009

Conspicuous Consumption Makes the News!

In today's New York Times came an article about the demise of conspicuous consumption because of the recession.  I am shocked!

What these kinds of articles do, however, is set up a dynamic (a conflict if you will) between the folks who believe this recession (I really really want to use the "d" key instead of the "r" key, and then a few "p's") is a cultural policy window and those who, like the current and past federal administrations, understand that unfortunately, our economy is dependent upon consuming.  Those who see this as a cultural policy window are savoring the moment of  "I told you so."  They saw the worst of the worst, the McMansions, the expensive cars, the gaudy jewels, the $1,000 Sex In The City Jimmy Choo shoes, and consistently (in their minds) said our culture was far too out on a consumption limb.  They are thoroughly enjoying the idea that we'll all give up our cars, our McDonald's Big Macs, and our Nordstrom credit cards for a simple life growing lettuce instead of grass in our front yards.

But then there are the folks who are coming late to this debate.  Laurie David and her stopglobalwarming.org who is currently on a rant about toilet paper.  This from a woman who lives in a huge mansion in LA and probably spends on clothing in a month what many of us spend in a year!  Or Arianna Huffington, who once wrote a piece about how many Blackberry phones she owned.

Culture wars or divisions will always be a part of our society.  And this combined rush for "sustainable" living (local food sources, green architecture, transportation etc) along with an energized policy initiatives on the environment, we may gradually move our culture toward a renewed sense of "just enough" rather than "too much."  But I think pundits expounding on how everyone else should live is not good.  If it's one thing we do well it's seeing through hypocrisy.  In order to sway a cultural shift, we  need to let the impacts of this depression (oops, recession) seep in as well as provide positive answers.  In other words, yes, we can all live well with two pairs of Jimmy Choos not four!  The reality is while this depression will alter all of our lives, it will not be a radical change in our culture.  Radical takes time.  A major concern is that while this depression will alter lives, it may also further expand the disparity between the rich and poor, further eliminating the middle class.  And that is not good at all.

But the good news is, we're beginning to have discussions in the "public town square" about how much stuff is enough.

Monday, March 9, 2009

How Big Dealers Deal With Foreclosure

In fairly remote areas (at least for this kind of money) wheeler-dealers began breaking ground on high end investments.  From McCall, Idaho to Big Sky, Montana, developers created special enclaves for the wealthy like The Yellowstone Club (Bill and Melinda Gates own property there) and Tamarack, in Idaho.  The Yellowstone Club boasted that you could only become a member if your net worth was over several million, then of course you had to spend hundreds of thousands every year in fees, much less what it cost to design and build your faux McMansion Log Cabin.  

These resorts carved golf courses, private ski areas, ponds, re-shaping the physical landscape as well as the economic topography of the regions.  Enormous wealth quickly sprung up in small towns across the Mountain West, such as Bozeman and McCall, where carpenters, plumbers, and log home contractors became instant celebrities and luscious magazines like Western Interiors tripped over themselves to show the world that the West was finally on the map with taste and wealth.

But as we know from physics, what goes up must come down, almost every one of these resorts are now in bankruptcy.  And the only ones making money are lawyers, expensive bankruptcy lawyers who fly in from New York, San Francisco, Chicago, to represent the lenders trying to figure out how to satisfy the investors who actually hold the promissory notes on the loans.  In other words, litigation is flying all over the place.  Of course, "the help," the carpenters, plumbers, and even the log cabin builders, all who are unsecured creditors, are left figuring out how to pay their own bills much less hire attorneys.

Meanwhile, these fancy resort bankruptcies show one thing.  While Congress continues to debate whether to reinstitute the ability of  bankruptcy judges to modify the terms of individual home owner's loans (called cram down provisions) which would help individuals maintain their homes, allow lenders to continue making a profit, these high powered borrowers have always been able to have judges modify their loans.  Why?  Because they are not individuals.  Corporations and owners of second homes do have the right to seek modifications.  But not an owner of a primary residence!  

Are you choking on your coffee, yet?

So instead of lessons about moral hazard which lenders argue is the problem with allowing individual cram downs, perhaps we out to be looking at the lessons of when the so-called wealthy file bankruptcy.  Where is the moral outrage?

Friday, March 6, 2009

What Economists Are Thinking About

Sometimes the best news isn't on the front page.  Yesterday it was in the New York Times arts section.  The article was entitled Ivory Tower Unswayed By Crashing Economy. 

While the article was about academic economists, it is also applicable to most disciplines, that exploring new ideas or theories is nearly impossible in an academic setting because of the intransigence of "elder" academic advisors.  But that is another piece of writing for another day.

What is clear is that both the mathematical modeling and the reliance on traditional economic theory, that is, people make rational economic decisions and the market automatically adjusts to respond to those decisions, is the prevailing overarching belief system of economists.

As a friend dryly said a few days ago, "corporations are not people."  Despite judicial precedent that allows corporations to have the same "rights" as individuals in this country, indeed, a corporation is not an human.  Rather it is a composition of many many people, making many many decisions, most of them based on their own self interest rather than the interests of shareholders, other employees, or even the so-called health of the company.

Behavioral economists, a "new" branch of economic theory, much disdained by the Free Market theorists, believe that economists must also evaluate decisions by using theories from psychology.  I would add anthropology and sociology.  Hopefully, these new behavioral economists become prevalent and the reliance on both Free Marketeers and mathematical modeling (which tends to make assumptions based on free market theory) diminishes.  

It will, I think, be interesting in time to read what these academicians begin to dissect as the causes of this current economic debacle.  There is plenty of places and people who made so-called rational decisions.  But clearly they were not in the best interests of anyone other than their pocket books.  But the irony is there are no such thing as free markets, and those who lined their own wallets did so with assists from tax breaks and now with bail outs.  Hopefully, economists begin to think about that, too.

Thursday, March 5, 2009

There's Something Reassuring About a Robin

As soon as there was a hint of light this morning, I heard Robins.  Robins, wrens, sparrows.  But it was the Robins that particularly caught my attention.  "Spring is on it's way," I said to myself, dodging the sudden shower while I ran uphill (is there no justice?).  

Our world right now is changing so rapidly my head feels foggy trying to keep up with the news.  Today, General Motors issued it's Annual Report and stated, essentially, that it's very existence is problematic.  I am young enough to remember "what's good for General Motors is good for the country."  And certainly that line has become even more evident as the policy makers count the number of jobs that will be in jeopardy if General Motors fails.  

In a magnificent display of gravity, home values continue to plummet, causing many people who believed they were accumulating some savings, to realize not only their security is gone, but the owe more than the house is worth.  

And the one economic sector which a mere two years ago was hot (retail sales) is now posting dismal figures, reminding us that we are all too afraid to spend money, much less credit.

But, this morning, there were the Robins.  As if to say life does go on, seasons do change, and sooner or later we will understand why the world seems so chaotic right now.

Wednesday, March 4, 2009

Hey, It's America!

I would never begrudge anyone trying to find silver linings in a disaster.  But, I think, there is something, well, er, distasteful in making a lot of money off the disaster you caused.  In an article that must have some public relations counsel squirming, former highly paid and highly placed executives of Countrywide Mortgage have a new company which acquires "sour" mortgages for pennies on the dollar.  The business model is to then contact the borrowers and work out a plan.  

Essentially this is the privatized model for what President Obama is proposing for the so-called toxic assets on banks books.  But here is the rub.   More than likely many of the sour loans this new company is acquiring were originated by Countrywide and it's progeny.  It's sort of like causing the tsunami then selling towels for the victims to dry off.  The sub-prime loans, teaser rates on adjustables, piggy-back loans, all those ideas originated with Countrywide and other "smartest men in the room."

Hey, it's America.  But really, isn't it time for us to question the morality of this business plan?