Friday, February 20, 2009

Laying Blame At The Wrong Place

In today's Wall Street Journal  former US Senator from Texas, Phil Gramm, opined on the economy.  Now, this is the same Phil Gramm who said this summer that we had become a nation of whiners.  And this is the same Phil Gramm whose wife was on the board of directors of Enron during the whole period of criminal activity led by Jeff Skilling and Ken Lay.  So, keeping that in mind, Mr. Gramm talked about what he perceives to be the two causes of the economic meltdown (another note, here, Mr. Gramm is an economist by training).

The first cause, he asserted, was monetary policy related to moving inventory which had stockpiled due to the September 11th recession.  By lowering interest rates as an incentive for businesses to borrow and acquire computers, machines, materials, the Federal Reserve also, in Gramm's opinion, threw fire on an already stable housing market, thus causing a sustainable market to become a boom.

But it's the second cause that I dispute.  Gramm has always been an opponent of the Community Reinvestment Act (CRA) which was originally signed into law by President Jimmy Carter as a result of glaringly obvious discriminatory lending practices by FDIC insured banks.  These discriminatory lending practices were known as redlining.  Essentially banks looked at maps, determined where the "poor sections" were and rarely if ever made a loan in those neighborhoods.  A redline was drawn around the area.

Now, the CRA was more of a feel good law than anything with regulatory teeth.  It simply "asked" banks to look at their loans and attempt to make investments in areas that they had previously redlined, as long as the investments were made with sound lending practices.  

It was not until 1989, under a Republican president, that some teeth was added to the law, which allowed community groups and researchers to access the lending information and perform more rigorous quantitative analysis on a bank's lending strategies.  But really, the whole idea of the CRA was more carrot than stick.  If a bank wanted to merge or to open more branches, the CRA was a vehicle for community groups to protest the expansion if the institution was not making investments in previously redlined communities.  However, not one bank merger or expansion was held up because of CRA complaints.

President Clinton further sought to open up the information on CRA based lending but did not promote any further regulatory bite.  In 1999, Mr. Gramm lead the charge to repeal the Depression era banking laws, commonly known as Glass-Steagall, and forced President Clinton to back off his ideas of strengthening the CRA by giving the FDIC and Office of Thrift Supervision more power to examine banks CRA compliance.  
In fact, in 2005, the Bush Administration did loosen the CRA requirements, allowing banks to include the acquisition of mortgage backed securities as a means of compliance.  In other words, banks looked at the zip codes of loans within the pool of mortgages and essentially said: "hey, there are some loans within a poor neighborhood, we're all good here!"  They were also allowed to include all of their services as part of the CRA "investments," so if a bank sold an annuity or a CD to someone within a suspect neighborhood zip code, it met the CRA "obligations."

Now folks like Mr. Gramm are maintaining the the CRA is responsible for sub-prime loans.

In fact, over 50% of all sub-prime loans made in the past 9 years, particularly those which are causing so much trouble, were made by non-federally regulated institutions.  Institutions not under the umbrella of CRA.  Another 25% to 30% came from banks, like Countrywide Bank (part of the infamous Countrywide "family") which are only partially obligated to follow the CRA.  

On the other hand, banks that did follow the traditional CRA requirements have significantly lower default rates.  They followed "sound business and lending practices."  They educated their borrowers on issues of credit, borrowing, and homeownership, instead of seeking the fast buck and selling the mortgage way down the road.

To blame a toothless law, intended to guide banks toward viewing the whole communities in which they lend, is gutless.  It reeks of sound bite moments that we witnessed during debates over welfare or other issues, when it became fashionable among some politicians to blame the poor because they didn't have expensive lobbyists in Washington, DC.  

In fact, if the numbers are accurate, it seems to me that strictly following the CRA may have saved some lenders from the crisis larger banks are now experiencing.  And those borrowers who were the beneficiaries of true CRA lending are also smiling as they sit at their kitchen tables in their homes.

Thursday, February 19, 2009

But Is It Enough?

Yesterday, President Barack Obama finally introduced his plan to help homeowners who are on the verge or in the throws of foreclosure.  In Washington State, as in numerous states across the nation, foreclosures are usually done without any intervention from the court.  Rather, notices of foreclosure are sent to the homeowner by the lender (or usually, through some foreclosure specialist who does this for a living) and the clock starts ticking.  In Washington, a homeowner has 180 days from the notice of foreclosure to come up with the delinquent payments plus accrued late fees, attorney fees (even though no attorney for the bank is involved), assessments for mailing, publishing costs...you get the drift.  And because these foreclosures are done without any judicial review, there are chances that a lot of foreclosures happen to folks who may not be in default, or who are close to coming up with the delinquencies but can't find a voice at the end of the phone at the lender to talk to.  And from this time last year when policy-makers started talking about the foreclosure crisis to yesterday, you can only imagine that there have been a lot of foreclosures.  A lot of families put into the streets.  A lot of stress, pain, and suffering.

Meanwhile, the least discussed part of the Obama plan is the stick he will ask Congress to impose if lenders do not cooperate in stemming some of the tide of foreclosures.  Currently in US bankruptcy law if you are in default of your mortgage and you file for bankruptcy, the only thing the bankruptcy court can do for you is to suggest you find the money to become current.  A bankruptcy judge can not "force" a lender to modify the loan.  However, this was not always the case, but the banking lobbyists got to Congress and the so-called cram down provisions were taken out of the bankruptcy code (a note here, if you're a corporation a bankruptcy court can "force" lenders to adjust terms of loans...gee, are we surprised?  And ironically, cram-down provisions are still legal for second homes and vacation properties...hmmm, who owns those I wonder?).  

Today, in the financial press, such as the Wall Street Journal, there is a lot of gnashing of teeth over the possible re-institution of the cram-downs.  And I ask again, what world are these financial institutions living in?  If these geniuses get what they want, they may end up owning every house in places like Nevada!

But here is the thing that caught my attention in listening to President Obama.  Several times in his speech he said that this plan would help "people who followed the rules."  The first time I noticed this kind of language was during the Clinton Administration.  The language is code for: "we're not going to help people who are poor, on welfare, or are not breaking their backs to make minimum wage."  For instance, the Obama foreclosure plan is specifically excluding people who "bought more house than they could afford."  Apparently, they did not follow the rules.  Or the plan is not designed to help people whose mortgage debt exceeds 105% of the current market value.  I guess those folks didn't follow the rules either.

Here's what I want to know:  First, who wrote these so-called rules?  Second, since when do politicians, who haven't followed very many rules themselves, get to dictate what rules are followed in a crisis like this?  Third, is it then true that the mortgage brokers who made gazillions of dollars and realtors who are driving around in their big honking Mercedes bought with their fat commissions after luring, purring, and assuring people that indeed they could afford this house, did they follow the rules?

My suggestion to politicians?  Lose the line about Americans who follow the rules.  We all know what you're trying to do, to assuage the few people left in America who may get upset that their tax dollars are being used for any bail out whatsoever.  But really, they will never be happy so why bother trying to assure them "only the rule followers" will be helped.

Frankly, if I were President, I would attempt to call a halt to foreclosures right now.  Suspend every single one of them.  1 in 10 homes in America are in some financial stress, whether it is worth less than the mortgage, in default, struggling to make payments, whatever.  That is a lot of folks.  Call a time out.  Ask Treasury to take 180 days to compile data on exactly what the problems are, where, who are the people, and what can we do to keep the greatest number of families in their homes.  Maybe we do mass cram-downs.  Wipe the slates clean of the consumer debt, cleaning up bank balance sheets as well, adjust the mortgages to where the greatest number of people stay put.  Backload the debt for a future sale.  Eliminate the due on sale clauses in Deeds of Trust so a borrower can sell the house without the buyer having to find a new loan.  There are tons of things we can be doing now to increase the numbers of people not losing their homes.

And oh, the next time, you know, in the next boom-bust cycle?  Let's make sure everyone knows what the rules are and follows them, so we're not segregating out people who simply got suckered.  Or we're not also bailing out the lenders, automotive manufacturers and whoever else has great lobbyists, who by the way, have never played by the rules.

Wednesday, February 18, 2009

Our Homes

Recently, the Pew Research Center finished a poll on American's attitudes toward their homes.  By this, I mean (and maybe so did Pew) the places American's want to consider home, not just the walls, but the location or ideal, as in near mountains, on a river...

During the past number of years, urban planners as well as hip transit engineers, have dreamed of a new American order, one where sprawl would be eliminated, people would move to cities, urban areas, and live in dense, transit oriented developments.  Now, with the real estate crash, these same urban planners believe the idea of a single family house is dead, and are piling dirt on the suburbs as well.  In fact, many of them have articulated the belief that the real estate crash is exhibit A that the single family home was "unsustainable."  They believe high density housing, clustered around urban amenities is the panacea to everything that irks them.

You can see the effects of this urban planning dream in small townhouse condominiums that sprouted like weeds in cities throughout the West (they are, in my aesthetic opinion, ridiculously designed and probably a developer's dream because they can be replicated over and over without any additional design costs to the developer).  These urban planners believe the single family house with a yard is wasted space, encouraging the suburbanization of America.  They tend to think folks who disagree with them are old guard, out of the mainstream, and not particularly environmental.

But the Pew Research shows that most Americans still want to live in a house with a yard, a fence, and in urban areas that have natural amenities (think Seattle, Portland, Denver).  In fact, one op-ed writer opined that American's want to live in those cities and have a garage filled with outdoor equipment (welcome to my world)!  

Increasingly, I think there is a polarization that is occurring in our society that may lead to as intense battles as the so-called blue/red polarities we currently witness.  This divide is over age and, for lack of a better word, entitlement.  The young, hip, urban planner types remind me of the young, hip, Wall Street types, or the young, hip, dot.com types of the late 1990s.  They know a lot.  And are not afraid to let you know they know a lot.  But they also feel they are entitled to being right.  A recent study on expectations of college grades demonstrates my point.

And so, these young urban planners are confident. They know that all the theories they studied, all the GIS maps they've done, all the European cities they have evaluated, are right.  Density is the trick.

But homogeneity is so un-American.  We don't want to look all the same.  We don't live all the same.  Many of us have kids who play sports, all over the city.  Some of us work from home and use our cars during the day to check on elderly parents.  Seniors like getting out and about, maybe even driving to the store or a mall just to look, to be around people.  Not everyone commutes to a downtown glass office building.  Those who want to live near natural amenities want to get out in them.  Not all of us want to live in cookie-cutter close in townhouses.  I think if we wanted to be Europe we'd have designed our communities based on those models decades ago.

I think about my friend who lives less than a mile from her office.  I have known her for over 30 years, and not once has she walked, biked, or even ridden the bus to work.  But she votes for every tax that will go to mass transit.  She's emphatic that we should have it.  But she has never used it to get from her single family detached house with a yard home to work.  She drives to work because she likes to meet with friends who don't work where she does for lunch, or see them for dinner.  Her car has given her a way to maintain a vibrant and vital life with her community.

While I appreciate what the young urban planners are trying to do, and applaud their ability to reach the ears of many politicians who sit through the transit oriented development seminars at their retreats held in swanky hotels far away from urban centers, I also think the young urban planners need to realize they are not the only ones living in urban centers.  Diversity is what makes us vital.  The Pew Research shows that just as much as we are hip and like Starbucks, the same survey on housing also showed that more Americans like McDonalds.  Now, perhaps the urban planners want to encourage more fast food chains near their transit oriented development?


Tuesday, February 17, 2009

What Are They Thinking?

In today's news, President Barack Obama is going to offer carrots to mortgage lenders in order to encourage them to reduce monthly payments of borrowers.  And of course, anything the federal government can do to help struggling home owners, owners who are either in default or on the verge of defaulting, is a good thing.  At least 6% of American home owners are either in foreclosure or on the verge.  That figure, of course, does not take into account the thousands who are struggling, who are not paying other bills in order to pay the mortgage, of the hundreds of thousands who have already mailed their house keys to lenders, or simply walked away.

But what really bothers me are two things.  First, lenders who are reluctant, no, objecting to helping any borrowers.  And second, the ya-hoos who say things like President Obama is running a risk of angering homeowners who are not in default and "bitterly" resent the government bailing out those who may have made bad decisions.  

First, the lenders.  It goes without saying that while there may be banks who are not taking any government money every single bank right now is benefiting from those who are seeking help from the Troubled Asset Relief Program (TARP).  On the idea that if one bank falters, especially one like Washington Mutual or Citibank or Bank of America, all the other banks suffer, then every bank should be responsive to direction from the government.  We, the taxpayers, are helping them survive in this economic climate.  So the lenders who say they can not do anything to help the borrowers and don't have an obligation to do so are really saying, what, they think holding on to empty real estate or selling it for a loss is a good thing because it proves you're man enough to foreclose?  And to the investors in the banks, or the ones who bought the collatoralized securities and are now apparently suing banks saying they have no right to suspend foreclosures (the banks, therefore, acting as mortgage servicers rather than owning the promissory note) I ask the same question: why would you want to hold onto vacant real estate.  It makes no sense given that the majority of foreclosures are happening in particular regions such as Southern California suburbs, Florida, Nevada.  Hello!  Lenders you foreclose and you end up with what?

Second, this whole argument about moral hazard is a straw man.  The idea comes from economic theory that if you have insurance you are less likely to guard against risk (as an aside, it seems the banks and other Lords of Wall Street sure knew a lot about moral hazard as they sliced and diced the mortgages to sell as securities in order to get them off their books).  In this context, of helping home owners reduce their mortgage payments, the moral hazard proponents seem to be arguing (using the term moral hazard as shorthand) that if the government helps homeowners now, a seed, a very bad horrible seed will be planted in American's minds that if they get into financial trouble, the government will always bail them out.

Done laughing yet?  

Seems to me that if you're robbed by a financial fraud, which evidence indicates many of the loans were done through dubious lending practices, you merit, in our society, help.  Let's not call this homeowners bail out, let's call it victim's assistance.  Victims of economic terror.  Victims of theft.  Victims of greed.

These bright bankers also think opposing re-instituting cram down provisions in bankruptcy laws is also a good idea.  Good Lord, banks lived with those provisions for decades before they finally contributed enough money to Democrats and Republicans in Congress to get them repealed.  Bankruptcy judges are not unreasonable wild-eyed populists who are going to make revisions to mortgages that will cause dire consequences to banks.  In fact, I would guess most cram-downs worked in the banks benefit before it was repealed.  Can our legislators please stop being afraid of bankers and their lobbyists?  They failed.  Repeat after me, they failed.  But for some reason (hmmm, do we need to check those campaign contributions, again?) Congress drags it's feet on re-instituting laws we all lived with for decades.  

If any of the Lords of Wall Street doubt that we are in an economic depression, look at the markets today, almost at the lowest point in a decade.  Look at how their own investors respond when they believe the Obama Administration is not doing enough to, oh, what is the word, bail out the banks.  It's time to look at helping the victims of this debacle, to make sure American's stay in their homes, that their kids stay in their schools, that their families share memories with their neighbors, that the local green grocery stocks the foods that family enjoys.  It's going to be a tiny amount of help in comparison to the monies banks are getting under TARP.

And hello, bankers?  Start thinking again, ok?

Friday, February 13, 2009

Rural Economies

The State of Washington has maintained it "trust" lands that were deeded to them by the federal government when it became a state.  These trust lands are required by federal law to maximize income for education, and thus, the trees are managed under a sustained yield model and sold for timber to the highest bidders.  Funds are then used for local schools and state universities and colleges.

However, with the economic meltdown, projections of income from these state trust lands has greatly diminished.  The state trust lands, which are distinct from other state own forest lands and federal forests, provided some of the last places where small timber companies and family owned logging operations could find, log, and mill wood.  Unfortunately, these small operations will probably not last during this recession.

What concerns me are the attitudes from primarily urban based environmental folks who see this decline and probably demise of small logging and milling operations as a good thing.  I could go on a rant about this, but only want to suggest that if we want to think about buying local as a good thing, then we ought to remember that includes wood products.  

As we begin to unravel what is in the economic stimulus package, I hope we begin to realize all boats are rising and falling on the same tide.  Rural, suburban, urban.  No one is better, all of us can be worse.

Thursday, February 12, 2009

Evolving Toward Acceptance

Along with every other scientist and romantic (who wouldn't find it romantic to sail in the South Pacific for five years studying nature?), I want to talk about Charles Darwin on the bi-centennial of his birth.

The Origin of Species over time has become a seminal work, but really to biologists, it is the progression of observed science along with work done by Carolus Linneaus among others.  For me the value of Darwin's work is the amazing beauty of a curious mind.  

While the theories of evolution have become, in the United States, a polarizing debate between those who believe that life was created from God and those who resent "believers" from not recognizing science, I would like to add a voice toward the idea that both the idea of creation and evolution theories can happily co-exist.  Here is a man, a naturalist, who wondered why, among many things, the beaks of finches in one area were slightly different than the beaks of finches in another place.  And from that curious mind, those astute observations, came a celebration, in my opinion, of the miracle of life, not a repudiation of God.

So today, on this amazing bi-centennial of genius, let's also be grateful that God gave us such a brilliant man, Charles Darwin.

Wednesday, February 11, 2009

Unable to Move

An interesting article in USA Today caught my eye as another consequence of the economic melt down (aka recession).  Because of the economy, and especially due to the real estate markets, Americans are unable to move to take another job.  One of the things that apparently that has been a strength of the American economy has been our mobility.  Unlike Europe, where people are reluctant to leave the towns and cities where they were born, Americans are willing to pack the kids in the car and head to other places for jobs.  

But given the inability for many to sell their homes for the amount they owe much less the costs of moving, this mobility seems to be another factor in daily deluge of bad economic news.  

Combine this news with the data that is indicating rural communities are being severely hit with the recession and we may be staring at a reverse of The Grapes of Wrath where instead of migrating to orchards, vineyards, and other farms in California, if there is any migration at all, it will be to the cities.  Of course, this has been a trend for the past several decades, but it leads me back to a point I made recently.  For all the discussions about bailing out Wall Street, the banks, and providing broadband service to rural communities, we need to think about maintaining, restoring, and creating jobs that actually make something.  This will mean we need to use some of our natural resources, we'll need to provide energy to factories, and we'll need to energize downtrodden communities.  

But we are not going to get ourselves out of this economic debacle by trying to revitalize the same economy we had until last year, and we certainly can not afford to import products from countries that do not maintain similar environmental or labor values that we do here.  It may mean we pay more for our products, but let's begin to make high quality furniture, televisions, automobiles, computers.  Then let's sell them to people overseas who want quality in design and function.  

Then, maybe then, moving doesn't become such a necessity.  Maybe we have communities where there are good jobs, a quality environment, and chances for movement within the economic strata.  Where the idea of mobility is about where we go for vacations not having to move to find another job.