Tuesday, January 13, 2009

Too Big to Fail?

I heard an interesting commentary yesterday.  The analyst said that when there is a corporation that is "too big to fail," something is very wrong with the world economy.  I would also add, that if something is too big to fail, and we're even at the juncture of talking about failing, then the corporation is also too big to be successful, which isn't that what capitalism is all about, being creating profits?

So here we are: Citibank is spinning off divisions.  Smith Barney is the first with more than likely others to follow.  And Citibank, having twice come to us, taxpayers, for money from the Troubled Asset Relief Program (TARP) will probably ask as third time for more money.

And here is the irony.  Somewhere out there some guy is opening his front door and a process server is serving him with a lawsuit.  The plaintiff?  Citicorp.  Why is he being sued?  Oh, maybe he stopped paying on his credit card, you know, made some bad decisions about his finances.  And the lawyers for Citicorp will play hard ball with this guy, taking as much money to pay the debt as they can get.  Yet, where is the accountability for Citicorp in it's own financial mess, the bad decisions it made, the creditors that don't get paid, much less the shareholders who are losing value on their investment?

No, I think it is time, now, for us to examine what it means "too big to fail."  In fact, I think when some corporation has become that big, it really isn't good for the global economy.  I mean, here we are with dark and dire warnings about what will happen to the international economy if/when Citibank fails.  Doom and darkness shall descend.  If a corporation gets to be so big that it's demise will actually impact the global economy, then something is really very wrong.  

Perhaps we have our priorities wrong.  I think the little independent two man mechanic shop down the road is too big to fail.  Or the dry cleaner's around the corner.  Or my vet clinic.  Or the green grocer that is a nice walk away.  

But Citicorp?  They have a history of bad decisions (raise your hands if you remember the Latin American loans?) yet they keep on ticking.  Where is the accountability?

Since I have written this, in Wednesday's New York Times there is an article about the banks needing even more money.  And then this small piece by a local columnist on how the banks are not lending to a small business here in Washington state.

Monday, January 12, 2009

Sustainable Economies

There are many things I never expected to write in one sentence.  The following is one of them: Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania may be an example of sustainable economies.  In a fascinating article from January 8, 2009 New York Times, Pittsburgh appears to have brought itself back from economic ruin when the steel mills closed and everyone ran from the city in the 1980s.

But the renewal of Pittsburgh's economy was not because of some instant "stimulus" but rather because of diligent efforts over years and years from dozens of sources to diversify the economy and to ensure that the region does not fall prey to boom and bust urges.

The down side to Pittsburgh's renewal has been a deindustrialization, which, I think, does a disservice to any economy.  Folks, we simply have to acknowledge that we need to make things.  It's one of the only ways for us to provide middle class jobs for skilled labor.

But much of the renewal of Pittsburgh came from retraining of steel workers.  And I think one of the most important elements of any "stimulus" plan has got to be a commitment to ensure we are providing employment, not just jobs, for people.  Hiring folks for construction jobs which may terminate when the bridge is built or for other infrastructure jobs is great as long as we are providing skills which can be translated into long term employment.  If we fail to do that, we are back at looming and chronic unemployment, which is, of course, not a good thing.

One  huge hurdle for any stimulus to work is the fact this economic melt down has crossed all sectors.  Journalists, mechanics from Boeing, aluminum workers, bankers, medical professionals, retailers, construction workers, real estate salespeople...and while education seems to so-far be insulated, we know that is not long.  Even the government, state, local, and federal agencies are at least in hiring freezes.  It is going to be very difficult to find areas where cash infusions are going to initiate long term employment.

In the meantime, maybe we need to really look at communities like Pittsburgh, long ago declared dead, rising from the ashes, and seemingly sustainable.


Friday, January 9, 2009

Media Closures, Layoffs and Democracy

Today's big news is local.  The Seattle PI, a Hearst owned newspaper, is going to either be sold or shut down.  We'll know more in 60 days.  However, as they say in the media business, sources say the likelihood of sale is nil, therefore the PI as we know it is essentially gone.

The PI is now in line with other venerable media outlets, such as the Detroit Free Press which recently announced it was scaling back it's home delivery of a physical newspaper, and media giants like CNN who laid off almost all of it's environmental reporting staff.   And of course, there were the huge layoffs from National Public Radio.  Just goes to show a huge endowment from Joan Kroc didn't insulate NPR from the economy!

Among media folks, there is a lot of speculation, blaming, and frustration over the demise of newspapers and news media in general.  Much of the finger pointing goes toward the Internet and the so-called democratization of "news."  Blogs such as Huffington Post, Daily Kos, Politico, which are essentially news aggregators, are believed to be the enemy of institutions such as The New York Times and yes, even the Seattle PI.  

Seattle has always thought of itself as a big city, and went through significant teeth-grinding when it thought the PI was going under in the early 1980s.  Backroom deals were hashed out by city fathers (think lots of cigar smoke and cognac at the Rainier Club) to keep both newspapers in business.  It was felt that having two newspapers reflected a sophistication, a sense that Seattle was a cosmopolitan city.  

While I have not been a big fan of either newspaper, and was ecstatic when I realized I could read both of them on-line for free, I do think this epidemic of layoffs, newspaper closures, and scale backs is, well, not a good sign for America or democracy.

Ok, here is my second qualification: I am also not a big fan of what has been termed "mainstream media."  Oh, I read a lot of it, listen to NPR, rarely watch TV news, but I do all of that with a large dose of cynicism.  I have not been a fan for a long time.  I suppose because having been involved in politics and being around reporters who, being frank here, are the best drinking buddies with politicians, the idea there is "objective" mainstream media is a crock.  And the so-called paper wall between income and reporting?  I can give you dozens, if not more, examples where that wall is a figment of someone's imagination.  

But, having said that, I am very concerned about the demise of these institutions.  I don't think  I need to go through the litany of great things much of the mainstream media has done: Pentagon Papers, Watergate, Arms for Hostages, current reporting on the economic melt down....think about this and add to this list yourself.  Quite frankly, Huffington Post  can not even begin to think about providing us those kinds of journalistic bomb-shells.  For whatever mainstream media has gotten wrong (the run-up to the Iraq war for instance) there have been hundreds of events they have gotten right, or close enough to right that we were able to peek into the abyss and see the muck.  

At a time when government is about to go through a huge expansion of it's role as well as it's power, even greater than with President Bush, when corporations are forced to consolidate, when financial chicanery impacts each of us, we need more watchdogs not less.  We need people who are not afraid to ask, probe, make nuisances of themselves, not accept a press release or former colleague who took a high paying job telling them what is up.  We need scientists, economists, psychologists, poets, willing to examine and write about the world around them.  And we need news not just from the glamourous capitals of the world, but from down the street, the next state, or a small town in the Midwest.  

There is a lot of fear right now.  No one knows if they are going to lose their job.  Boeing, the Seattle PI,  Aloca, Washington Mutual, the list goes on of layoffs, reductions, hiring freezes.  Now, more than ever, we need courage, a willingness to write, to report, to explain.  We need fearlessness, an ability to withstand the anger people share in the comment sections (have you ever noticed the vitriolic crap that gets written in the comment sections of these web sites?  Scary).  Most of all we need an understanding that abandoning news, or allowing media to write it's own obituary, is the worst thing for democracy.  Our information then becomes a battle between garbage fed by government, corporations, or some publicist versus someone like Ariana Huffington deciding whether she wants to argue with the press release or not.  It become superficial and all about ego and power.  And no one other than those well connected people participate.  That is not democracy.

So, if the PI goes down, I say we all take up pens and paper, make press credentials, and hit the streets.  It's our duty.

Thursday, January 8, 2009

Tax Credits?

Several days ago, President-elect Barack Obama announced that he was including in his economic stimulus package tax credits.  An individual could get as much as $500 and a couple up to $1,000.  While I am no fan of paying taxes and believe that often our tax money is wasted (nope, I happen to think the DNA study on Northern Rocky Mountain Grizzlies was a good thing, but don't get me started on the things I think are a waste, like all the opulent offices for Members of Congress...)I am a little concerned about these tax credits.

As he was announcing the tax credits, President-elect Obama was also voicing his concern over the record deficits in our national budgets.  And of course, given the apparent need for Keynesian economics the national deficit will increase to levels unimaginable even a decade ago.  A brief econ 101 here: when the federal government has a budget with a deficit, they have to raise money to pay for things that are over and above the income (taxes) they bring in.  So, the government can either print money and cause inflation (think Zimbabwe with astounding inflation) or they can sell treasury bills, which is essentially borrowing money.  And the problem with borrowing money is that the federal government is, simplistically put, competing with us for a finite amount of lender's dollars.  If you're a lender, who would you rather lend to, the US government or a private business?  Deficit spending essentially inhibits private sector economic growth.  There is also that dicey moral issue of having our children, grandchildren, and great-grandchildren pay for our current services, since that is when the debt is paid off, many many years in the future.  Much less the issues surrounding who the government borrows money from: China, governments in the Middle East...

Ok, so giving tax credits will further increase the deficit.  

Many of my progressive friends object to the tax credit because it appears to be appeasing the Republicans, who they blame for this whole economic melt-down.  The reality is, in Washington, DC, policy is not made with out compromise.  And trust me, there are a lot of Democrats who also want a tax credit.

Obama justifies the tax credit as "putting money back into the pockets" of those who need it the most.  I disagree.  

Let me ask you, does the elderly woman who tries to get her prescriptions filled and is told the cost is over $600, she lives on Social Security and has to make a decision to eat or buy drugs, much less pay rent, transportation costs, utilities...you get the drift, does she even pay taxes?  Nope.  But could she use $500 cash to help pay some monthly bills?  Or more importantly, a whole revision of the so-called prescription drug benefit so our senior citizens are not put into embarrassing situations at the drug store.  Really, I believe the people who could use the tax credit the most are the people who don't pay taxes.  Poor people spend money (and hence stimulate the economy) because they have to.  Moderately well off people can take the tax credit and save it, thus not stimulating the economy, which is what we saw in the refund checks the summer of 2008.

As exhibited by the amount of time I spend on this issue, President-elect Obama has a huge nightmare on his hands.  Today I heard that for every available job in this country, 3.1 people are seeking it.  And that if, by the height of this economic melt-down, unemployment increases by 50%, it would make approximately 10 people seeking every job.  Those are scary numbers.  Clearly a whole range of policies must be implemented to prevent a national disaster, or at least mitigate the one we are in.

Without running the numbers, my guess is that legislating this proposed tax credit will not eventually cost the federal budget very much money, but it makes Obama sound reasonable, concerned about the middle class, and bi-partisan.  It is in a sense giving him money in the bank to perhaps ask Congress for subsequent measures which may be controversial, such as overhauling the health care insurance system.  

But the reality is it will not alone or even with his other proposals, be a significant stimulus to the economy.  It's just an example of how the games of politics are played.


Wednesday, January 7, 2009

Gas Tax

Recently, the New York Times editorial board encouraged Congress and the Obama Administration to increase the federal gas tax.  Their reasoning is, of course, that the more we pay at the pump the less we consume.  Which is traditional economic theory.

There is some good policy reasons behind this idea.  Oil, whether we are at peak oil or not, probably is a finite resource.  And clearly, as we witnessed during the summer of 2008, global consumption has vastly increased, causing prices here in the US to soar suddenly and with consequences to consumer's pocketbooks.  On the global security front, relying on international sources for oil obviously dictates our foreign policy in ways which probably cause diplomats to cringe.  We are held hostage to our consumption.

Decreasing that dependence as well as conserving a resource that no matter what, we will continue to use, is good public policy.

However, here we are teetering on a depression the breadth and depth is probably unknown to us.  The fact gas prices have declined is a good thing for most Americans, freeing up dollars to spend on food, clothing, education (and yes, a flat screen TV).  For those of us who heat with fuel oil, certainly the decline in oil prices is helping (I can actually feel comfortable turning on the heat!).

The reality is that our whole economy is wrapped up with oil.  Not just for cars driving in cities, but fertilizers for farming, resins for plastics, and jet fuel, to name a few.  While the proponents of an increased gas tax appear to only be leveling their tax at gasoline, whole economies will suffer having to pay more for gas.  For instance, not everyone lives in a city.  Rather, farmers and ranchers, from who we get our food, have to use lots of gasoline.  Increases in prices could severely hurt them.  Or what about the families that are trying to keep kids off the streets by participating in after school or Saturday programs, where a parent is required to shuttle their children across town?  

The one-size fits all policies attempting to solve environmental issues only backfires, causing resentment for taxing or regulation based solutions.

Rather, we need to look at our oil consumption issues much more holistically and broadly.  For instance, Wes Jackson and Wendell Berry have written about totally revising our farming policy.  

Their ideas are an example of how we need to seek solutions that have a much longer and larger view.  That are incentive based and help people live quality lives, not struggle trying to figure out how they can get by or around government policies.  Encouraging perennial crops in order to use less fertilizer and stabilize the soil (a natural resource if there ever was one) seems simple but will take lots of effort to overcome a century of farm policies intended to grow crops by pummeling the land.  But their suggestions are long sighted and can help reduce our dependence on oil.

Before we decide to attempt standard economic theory to change people's behavior, we really do need to understand all the consequences.  

In the meantime, walking is a good thing!

Since writing this, President-elect Barack Obama announced the appointment of Cass Sunstein as an advisor.  Sunstein, who taught at University of Chicago School of Law and is now at Harvard (also married to Obama's foreign policy advisor, Samantha Powers) is a proponent of behavioral economics, which, among other things, encourages, for lack of a better word, nudges, inducements, to get people to "behave" differently.  I suspect he would not support an increase in the gas tax.


Tuesday, January 6, 2009

Is There Objective Science?

Many of my ecologist colleagues are practically wearing out their computer keyboards emailing sign-on letters to President-elect Barack Obama encouraging him to stop the demeaning of science.  Implied in the contents of the letter is that the current Administration has somehow denigrated science.  Also implied in the letter is a belief that there is an ability to have objective science.  That somehow, science, this amorphous "discipline" consisting of everything from the study of nature to the examination of esoteric principles of physics, is neutral from the scientist performing the research.  

Whenever I hear a scientist say they are objective, I'm sorry, but I laugh.  It's as if they somehow perceive of their work outside of themselves.

And what, you wonder, started this train of thought?

Ever since I was in graduate school, I have been on a number of list servs.  One of them is related to all thing ecological.  It's managed by a professor of ecology in Maryland.  Most of the postings have to do with job announcements.  But occasionally, the group (and I don't know how many people are served by this list) engages in lively debates on topics such as the teaching of evolution (they are overwhelmingly for it), steady state economic theory (always interesting, trust me), research methodology, and abuse of graduate assistants (mostly led by abused graduate assistants).  Now, this list is of academic ecologists, wildlife biologists, oceanographers, fisheries people, foresters, zoologists, you get the picture.  They take offense at people who may refer to them as environmentalists, because they perceive of themselves as scientists not advocates.  

But today, someone innocently sent an email announcing the publication of Courting the Wild: Love Affairs With the Land.  And in response to this email, which also included a sound bite review by Paul Ehrlich, someone emailed back saying he thinks this kind of book, rhapsodizing about wondrous places, does a disservice to objective science.  His critique boils down to a sense that place based or charismatic mega-fauna oriented (think big bears, mountain lions, wolves) literature detracts from other, far less glamourous species that provide enormous "service" to ecosystems.  Now, I happen to think that the mychrorrizel  that attaches to the roots of Douglas fir (pseudotsuga menziesii) is pretty darn sexy, but apparently I am in a minority.  

What is more interesting about this critique is it stimulated an interesting debate about science.  The writer finished his rant about the book by saying he was a scientist and engages in objective based science.  There should be no love involved.

I smiled when I read his email.  I wondered what exactly he does every day to remove himself from his work.  In other words, how can he be objective?  Every single one of us bring our histories, our lives, our emotions with us when we begin our days.  Try as we might to subordinate feelings, we are human.   I thought about the wonderful idea that scientists bring poetry to what we see and poets bring science to what we read.

But really, what this debate is about is defining terms like "best available science," or "good science."  These are terms that are bandied about particularly among the environmental advocacy community.  Or the quasi-advocacy community.  Or even sometimes among the regulatory communities.  And I always wonder who is deciding what is "good science" or "the best available science."  Of course, as someone trained in research methodology, I understand things like peer review, hypothesis driven, replicable experiments.  But it seems to me when you use terms like "best available" or "good" objectivity is thrown out the window.  In other words, to get to that point, subjective decisions had to have been made.

Which leads me to two points.  First, in my opinion place or charismatic fauna based literature is not over looking all the flora and fauna that make a spot or animal tick.  While there may not be amazing pictures of worms or ugly slugs, I believe we are generally aware that there is more to the picture than meets the eye.  I think about my friend Dave.  He is a fly fisherman who has an amazing ability to fish places that are not the see and be seen rivers, but rather small, tiny streams probably not on any GPS systems.  Yet, for every moment Dave is on the stream, he is aware of the magic of the ecology, from large animals to the oxygen and hydrogen molecules in the water.  And while he may photograph the scenic, he is always thankful for the minute, the small, unseen magic that composes the picture.  Scientists must not think the rest of the world is dumb and does not appreciate what is not before them.

Second, when we talk about "good" or "best available" science, let's be real, as they say.  What we really mean is science that agrees with the conclusion we are looking for.  Whether it is showing pesticide risk to salmon, diminishing populations of Black footed ferrets, or impacts of global climate change on Polar bears, frequently what is considered good or best available is that science which demonstrates our own prejudices.  Remember, science is about variables.  What was "proven" in ecology as recently as a decade ago, has been challenged last week.  There were many decisions made by this current Administration that were based on science: the attempted de-listing of the Northern Rockies wolves off the endangered species list for example, which wildlife advocates derided as not "good" science.  While I may have disagreed with many decisions made by this Administration, I, frankly, did so based on policy reasons, not denigrating their science.  Who am I to say my science is better?

So while I join in encouraging the new President to emphasize science, particularly the ecological sciences, let's also encourage this Administration to enjoy sunsets over the Grand Tetons, howling wolves in the Lamar Valley, the deep blue water of Lake Tahoe, icicles hanging off of bare maples and oaks in the Shawangunks, a hulking Bison in the Badlands, and the full moon off the snow in Bosque del Apache.  Then they will hopefully understand the delightful mix of love and science.

Exhibit A


The Wall Street Journal printed an article on January 3, 2009 that is Exhibit A in what I have been discussing about the financial industry.  This house, or shack, was appraised at $132,000 and received a loan, a "no-doc" loan for $103,000.  It was unfit for human occupancy (or any other occupancy for that matter!).  Now, there could be an argument that the land was worth that amount, but the reality is someone had to pay that loan.  You have to read the story to understand that there is no way, no way, the lender should have made the loan.

Indeed, we can blame the borrower.  She was on a fixed income, a mix of disability, food stamps, welfare to work for a total of $3,000 a month.  She probably knew she could not afford an adjustable rate mortgage with an introductory rate of 9.5%.  But come on, isn't the lender, the mortgage broker, responsible for something here?  Turns out she was telemarketed.  Yep, someone called and told her to apply for the loan.  Then they paid for an appraisal.  They assured her she would qualify.  And the mortgage broker didn't just arrange for one loan, he made sure she got two, one his own firm lent her!

Of course, this is an extreme example.  But the bottom line is that we, as a community, will pay for this travesty, along with others that are more nuanced but as egregious.  Frankly, I regret not writing on the outside of the hundreds of direct mail pieces I received from Washington Mutual, Bank of America, Countrywide, and others: stop sending me these offers, it is immoral.  But I didn't.  

Now what?  Well, I think we begin by understanding everyone shoulders the blame.  Not just the greedy mortgage broker or the bottom-of-the-rung woman in this story.  We all went nuts during the past two decades.  We spent money we didn't have.

Second, I think we begin to realize our homes are not investments, but homes.  We live here.  We raise children here.  We sit by the fire and read.  We have holidays dinners at home.  We slam doors when we're angry and pop champagne corks when we celebrate.  We buy a house or condo as our home.  It's great that the house appreciates in value, and fantastic that we add value to it by restoring or remodeling.  But it is a home.  Using it as our credit card is not only unwise, but it changes the meaning of a place that shelters us.   It is not a home but similar to a piece of plastic with a name, number, and expiration date.  This change, from realizing our homes are not investments, is cultural.  It will be a huge shift in how the lending industry has led us to think during the past 8 or so years.  It will be hard, but a wise cultural shift to make.

Third, while this is hard for me to assert, we need some accountability.  I have yet to look at court dockets, but I can imagine there will be a lot of litigation over the predatory loans.  While I think litigation will be good, it more than likely will only name corporations as the defendants.  There are a lot of individuals in the mortgage industry that made a lot of money and who should also be held at least civilly accountable.  I would also think a few criminal prosecutions for fraud might be a good deterrent.

Our community took a hit.  We all let this happen.   Now it's up to us to fix it.  We need a habitat for humanity that fixes our culture.